When Is The Right Time To Estimate In Scrum
Agile estimation is a collaborative process where Scrum teams approximate the effort required to complete user stories and tasks. Unlike traditional project management, Scrum estimation focuses on relative sizing using story points rather than absolute time predictions, enabling teams to deliver value incrementally.
Key timing considerations:
Product Backlog estimation should happen before Sprint Planning
Sprint Backlog estimation occurs during Sprint Planning
Re-estimation happens when new information emerges
Continuous refinement throughout the project lifecycle
Why Estimation Still Matters in Scrum
Sprint Planning Capacity: Teams need to understand how much work they can realistically commit to in a sprint
Stakeholder Communication: Provides transparency about progress and delivery timelines
Resource Planning: Helps organizations make informed decisions about team composition and project scope
Continuous Improvement: Historical estimation data enables teams to improve their planning accuracy over time
Risk Management: Identifies potentially complex or risky work items early
The Misunderstanding: "Scrum Says No Deadlines" Myth
Reality Check: Scrum doesn't eliminate deadlines; it changes how teams approach them
Empirical Planning: Teams use historical data and sprint outcomes to make informed commitments
Transparent Communication: Regular estimation and velocity tracking provide stakeholders with realistic expectations
Adaptive Planning: Estimation enables teams to adjust scope and timelines based on actual progress
Business Value Focus: Helps prioritize features that deliver maximum value within available time
Connecting Estimation to Empirical Process Control
Transparency:
Clear visibility into team capacity and progress
Shared understanding of work complexity
Open communication about challenges and dependencies
Inspection:
Regular review of estimation accuracy during retrospectives
Velocity tracking to identify improvement opportunities
Sprint Review discussions about completed vs. planned work
Adaptation:
Adjusting estimation techniques based on team learnings
Refining Product Backlog items as more information becomes available
Modifying sprint commitments when circumstances change
Understanding the Purpose of Estimation in Scrum
For Product Owners:
Prioritize backlog items based on value vs. effort
Make informed decisions about scope and release planning
Communicate realistic expectations to stakeholders
For Development Teams:
Break down complex work into manageable pieces
Identify technical dependencies and risks early
Foster collaborative understanding of requirements
For Scrum Masters:
Facilitate productive planning conversations
Identify impediments to effective estimation
Coach teams on improving estimation practices
Common Points in the Scrum Cycle Where Teams Estimate
Product Backlog Refinement:
Story point estimation for upcoming user stories
Relative sizing using techniques like Planning Poker
Breaking down large epics into smaller, estimable stories
Sprint Planning (Part 1):
Reviewing pre-estimated Product Backlog items
Confirming team capacity for the upcoming sprint
Adjusting estimates based on new information
Sprint Planning (Part 2):
Task-level estimation in hours
Breaking user stories into specific development tasks
Identifying dependencies and technical considerations
Daily Scrum (When Needed):
Re-estimating remaining work on in-progress tasks
Identifying when original estimates need adjustment
The Pros and Cons of Estimating at Different Times
Early Estimation (Product Backlog Refinement)
Pros:
More time for thoughtful consideration
Less pressure than during Sprint Planning
Enables better long-term planning
Cons:
May lack detailed requirements understandingEstimates might become outdated
Risk of over-engineering solutions
Just-in-Time Estimation (Sprint Planning)
Pros:
Based on most current information
Team has clearer understanding of requirements
Direct connection between estimation and commitment
Cons:
Time pressure can lead to rushed decisions
May not allow for adequate discussion
Can delay Sprint Planning if estimates are complex
Continuous Re-estimation
Pros:
Adapts to new information and learnings
Maintains accuracy throughout development
Supports empirical process control
Cons:
Can be time-consuming if overdone
May create confusion about commitments
Requires discipline to avoid endless re-estimation
Factors Influencing the "Right Time" to Estimate
Team Maturity:
New teams benefit from more frequent, collaborative estimation
Experienced teams can estimate more efficiently with less overhead
Team dynamics and communication patterns affect optimal timing
Project Complexity:
Complex projects require more upfront estimation effort
Simple, well-understood work can be estimated just-in-time
Technical uncertainty influences estimation frequency
Stakeholder Needs:
External reporting requirements may dictate estimation timing
Funding decisions often depend on early estimates
Customer expectations influence estimation cadence
Organizational Context:
Company culture around planning and predictability
Integration with other teams and projects
Regulatory or compliance requirements
Best Practices for Timing Estimates
The 80/20 Rule:
Estimate at least 80% of Product Backlog items before the first sprint
Focus detailed estimation on items likely to be worked on soon
Keep distant items at epic level until they move up in priority
Rolling Wave Planning:
Detailed estimates for immediate sprints (next 2-3 sprints)
Medium-level estimates for near-term work (next 2-3 months)
High-level estimates for longer-term planning
Definition of Ready:
Establish criteria for when items are ready for estimation
Include acceptance criteria, dependencies, and constraints
Ensure shared understanding before estimation sessions
Regular Refinement:
Schedule recurring backlog refinement sessions
Limit estimation sessions to maintain team energy and focus
Review and adjust estimation practices in retrospectives
Tools and Techniques to Support Timely Estimation
Digital Planning Tools:
Online Planning Poker platforms for remote teams
Story mapping tools for visual prioritization
Burndown and velocity tracking dashboards
Estimation Techniques by Timing:
Quick Estimates: T-shirt sizing, affinity mapping
Detailed Estimates: Planning Poker, bucket system
Re-estimation: Three-point estimation, risk-adjusted estimates
Team Rituals:
Estimation parties for large backlog refinement
Mini-estimation sessions during Daily Scrums
Retrospective review of estimation accuracy
Why Product Backlog Estimation
Strategic Planning Benefits:
Enables long-term roadmap development with realistic timelines
Supports release planning and milestone setting
Helps identify resource needs and team capacity requirements
Prioritization Support:
Allows Product Owners to balance business value against development effort
Reveals hidden complexity that might affect priority decisions
Supports cost-benefit analysis for feature development
Team Alignment:
Creates shared understanding of work complexity across the team
Facilitates technical discussions about implementation approaches
Builds collective ownership of delivery commitments
Stakeholder Communication:
Provides data-driven insights for executive reporting
Enables transparent communication about project progress
Supports funding and resource allocation decisions
Why Sprint Backlog Estimation
Sprint Planning Effectiveness:
Helps teams determine realistic sprint capacity
Enables balanced workload distribution among team members
Identifies potential bottlenecks and dependencies early
Daily Progress Tracking:
Provides baseline for measuring daily progress
Enables early detection of scope or timeline issues
Supports adaptive planning within the sprint
Quality Assurance:
Encourages teams to think through implementation details
Identifies testing and integration requirements upfront
Reduces the risk of incomplete work at sprint end
Continuous Improvement:
Generates data for retrospective analysis
Helps teams understand their actual vs. estimated capacity
Supports velocity calculation and trend analysis
Task-Level Benefits:
Breaking stories into tasks reveals implementation complexity
Encourages collaboration and knowledge sharing
Creates clear accountability for individual contributions
Conclusion
We recommend you to take up the CSM Certification Training at StarAgile institute and be certified in the scrum. StarAgile is the training partner of Scrum Alliance Certification Inc to deliver the certified scrum master online training.
