Disciplined Agile Vs SAFe

Enterprises often consider Discipline Agile Vs SAFe when choosing the proper framework. SAFe Framework and Disciplined Agile (DA) are the two prominent methodologies that have emerged in enterprise-level Agile software. Both methods aim to improve efficiency and speed but differ in principles and emphasis. SAFe focuses on governance alignment and standardization, while Disciplined Agile focuses on flexibility, choice, and context-driven decisions. 

How can you determine which philosophy best suits your organization? Should I take a hybrid approach? This blog explores these differences in detail, helping you examine the key features of each methodology and choose the one that best suits your organizational needs.

Let’s first examine SAFe and Disciplined Agile individually. I will then provide a detailed introduction to each. 

What is Disciplined Agile?

Disciplined Agile is a hybrid tool kit that guides your organization's best way of working(WOW). The tool kit harnesses hundreds of Agile methodologies for business agility. DA teaches you how to choose and evolve the way of working based on your situation. It integrates strategies from various traditional methodologies to approach challenges comprehensively.

The DA toolkit provides straightforward guidance in context-sensitive matters and helps organizations streamline their process. It describes the business functions and addresses a range of options to describe tradeoffs- associated with each option. DA also shows how businesses should function in solution delivery, IT operations, and other work. Rather than providing a specific set of practices, they help enterprises tailor their practices flexibly.

Enroll for the SAFe Training in Delhi to master essential skills like PI planning, portfolio management, and continuous delivery. 

What is SAFe?

Scaled Agile Framework(SAFe) is a structured framework designed to help large organizations scale Agile practices across multiple teams, departments, and business units. It provides a clear set of guidelines, roles, and workflows to ensure alignment, collaboration, and efficient Agile implementation at an enterprise level.

SAFe integrates Lean, Agile, and DevOps principles to improve productivity, quality, and time-to-market. It includes structured planning mechanisms like Program Increment (PI) Planning, Agile Release Trains (ARTs), and Lean Portfolio Management, ensuring teams work towards common business objectives.

SAFe is best suited for large organizations looking for a structured and scalable Agile approach, enabling them to adapt to market changes while maintaining governance and efficiency.

Master SAFe Agile Framework with our SAFe Training

Download Brochure

 

Disciplined Agile Vs SAFe: A Detailed Comparison

1. Prescriptive

• Disciplined Agile(DA) is flexible and adaptive. Rather than enforcing a single framework, DA is a decision-making toolkit that helps teams and organizations choose their way of working (WoW). It also incorporates Scrum, Kanban system, Lean in its methods.  Disciplined Agile allows teams to tailor their Agile approaches based on their needs and situations. 

• SAFe (SAFe) is highly prescriptive. The structured framework makes it ideal for organizations that are looking for governance and alignment across cross functional teams. The well defined roles and responsibilities makes this framework more appealing for these organizations.Organizations adopting SAFe must follow a standardized approach, including Agile Release Trains (ARTs), Program Increment planning, and predefined workflows. 

2. Core Philosophy

• Disciplined Agile (DA) on the other hand, is more flexible and adaptable. Instead of prescribing a single approach, DA provides a toolkit that allows organizations to choose their way of working (WoW) based on their context. It integrates best practices from multiple Agile methodologies, including Scrum, Kanban, Lean, SAFe, and DevOps.

• SAFe follows a top-down implementation providing a step-by-step approach to scale Agile. The structured and prescriptive framework emphasizes alignment, planning, and standardization across teams. 

3. Structure and Framework

• Disciplined Agile (DA) does not impose a single framework. The organizations get to explore various Agile maturity models based on the needs. The  decision-making toolkit that helps organizations customize Agile best practices based on their needs. It encourages organizations to explore different Agile models and choose the most effective approach.

• SAFe: SAFe is a well-defined framework with multiple configurations, including Essential SAFe, Large Solution SAFe, Portfolio SAFe, and Full SAFe.

4. Prescriptive Vs. Adaptive Approach

• Disciplined Agile (DA) is adaptive and allows organizations to tailor their Agile transformation based on existing practices. It does not enforce specific roles but guides which techniques may work best in a given situation.

• SAFe is highly prescriptive and provides specific guidelines, artifacts, and ceremonies that organizations must follow. It includes predefined roles such as Product Owners, Scrum Masters, Release Train Engineers (RTEs), and Solution Architects.

5. Implementation and Adoption

• Disciplined Agile (DA ) supports a bottom-up approach, enabling organizations to evolve their Agile practices over time. It is more customizable, making it suitable for organizations with Agile experience but wanting to refine their approach.

• SAFe follow a top-down approach, making it ideal for organizations choosing a systematic Agile. The top-down approach provides a structured framework for scaling Agile in the organization. The workflow is achieved easily by the pre-defined roles.

6. Focus Areas

• Disciplined Agile (DA) prioritizes flexibility, choice, and continuous improvement, making it ideal for organizations that require a context-driven Agile approach.

• SAFe: SAFe focuses on alignment, governance, and scaling Agile across large enterprises. It is best suited for organizations that need a clear roadmap to Agile transformation.

Disciplined Agile Vs SAFe: The Right Choice for Your Company?

The right approach for your organization is crucial. SAFe and Disciplined Agile offer customized solutions for organizations. But you choose yours by:

• Goals: If your goal is to implement agile best practices as quickly and efficiently as possible, SAFe might be the right choice, as it provides a more comprehensive set of tools and guidelines. However, if you are more interested in building a culture of agility responsive to changing business needs over time, disciplined agile might be better for you since, as discussed earlier, disciplined agile focuses on helping organisations adopt agile practices at all enterprise levels.

• Size: SAFe is specifically designed for large organisations. Hence, SAFe is a good choice if you are a large organisation with multiple teams and a need to coordinate work across different departments and functions. If your company is smaller, disciplined agile might be a better fit. 

• Culture: If your organization values higher flexibility and adaptability, then disciplined Agile is better. SAFe might be a good fit if your organization values structure and predictability. Its formal frameworks and practices can provide a clear roadmap for implementing agile at scale. 

The Future of SAFe and Disciplined Agile 

The key trends expected in SAFe and Disciplined Agile are: 

1. Adaptability and Customization 

Not everything fits in one size. SAFe and DA  are expected to offer customizable options to tailor Agile practices based on the organization's size. This adaptability promotes flexible implementation of Agile practices among teams.

2. AI-Driven practices 

AI-powered solutions are crucial in making data-driven decisions and optimizing workflow by automated tasks. The advanced AI-driven tools enhance the virtual collaboration among teams irrespective of their mode of work 

3. Integration with DevOps Practices

The integration of DevOps is set to deepen continuous integration, delivery, and deployment. Therefore, the culture of collaboration between operation and development teams will naturally be achieved. The convergence of Agile and DevOps is set to bring continuous integration of DevOps to increase workflow and enhance productivity.

4. Focus on Value Stream Management

Developments of  SAFe and Disciplined Agile are expected to emphasize value in every step of development and stream value management. This focus in the development process will help the organization identify and eliminate backlogs, delivering higher-quality products and services.

5. Wide Adoption 

SAFe and DA are set to undergo tremendous changes in expanding Agile beyond IT(information technology). Creating a culture of collaboration and responsiveness across all departments increases productivity and delivery rate. Features like flexibility and customization achieve this

Overall, SAFe and disciplined agile can be practical approaches to implementing agile at the enterprise level. However, the right strategy for your organisation will depend on your specific needs and goals. SAFe is the right choice if you are a large organization looking for a formal and prescriptive approach to implementing agile at scale. On the other hand, disciplined agile for smaller organizations.  Ultimately, the key is to find a strategy that works for your organisation and helps you deliver value to your customers through rapid iteration and continuous delivery.

Bottom Line

Take your Agile career to the next level with SAFe Certification from StarAgile! Learn how to scale Agile, improve collaboration, and lead enterprise-level transformations with expert guidance and a globally recognized credential.